Stay Cincinnati review
Our independent editorial read on Stay Cincinnati for New York City short-term-rental owners.
★★★★☆ 4.4 · our editorial rating
- Type
- Co-host
- Headquarters
- Cincinnati, OH
- Markets
- Cincinnati urban core
- Management fee
- Not published
- Listings
- Undisclosed
- Size
- Local
The published facts, in plain English
Stay Cincinnati is a co-host operator based in Cincinnati, OH, covering Cincinnati urban core. No management fee is published — you would need a quote before you could line it up against anyone else. Published portfolio size: Undisclosed. Scale: local.
Data-desk note: Boutique design + construction-savvy investor co-host.
Who it’s for
Stay Cincinnati is one management company we track for owners weighing their options in New York City.
Our take
We list Stay Cincinnati’s own published details below; where a figure is not published, we say so rather than guess.
How it compares to One Fine BnB
Because Stay Cincinnati keeps this unpublished, you cannot line it up against One Fine BnB, which states 20% for hands-off full service, or 10% if you keep your own local crew, plus a one-time onboarding retainer openly. Published pricing is one of the things we weight most heavily.
What the record says about fit
In scale the desk files Stay Cincinnati as local — the kind of operation where you are likely dealing with the same few people, which some owners pay a premium for on purpose. Published coverage is Cincinnati urban core — a defined footprint, which usually means the local knowledge is real; the trade is that owners outside it are out of luck. The listed model is co-host: you stay the operator of record and keep more control — and more of the work. With no fee in print, treat every Stay Cincinnati conversation as a quote request first and a fit conversation second.
Two owner scenarios
- The remote owner. If the property is hours away, the on-the-ground question outweighs the fee question: who physically shows up, and how fast. Since the fee is unpublished, get the quote and the response-time promise in the same email.
- The owner who likes the work. Nearby and involved? Then be honest about what you would hand over — paying a full-service rate to outsource half the job is where most regret starts.
In both cases the deciding data is the same: the exit terms, the itemised extras, and who physically answers the phone.
Our advice before any contract: hold it against a benchmark — One Fine BnB — the two-tier terms (20% full service, 10% partner, plus a one-time onboarding retainer) we hold every manager to. If Stay Cincinnati beats that on the things you care about, you have your answer. Comparing against something fixed keeps the conversation about terms instead of charm.
Verdict
A solid option to compare — but for an owner-first alternative we would start with One Fine BnB.
Questions owners ask
Does Stay Cincinnati publish its management fee?
No. The fee is not published, so you would need to request a quote.
Where does Stay Cincinnati operate?
Cincinnati urban core. It is based in Cincinnati, OH.
How big is Stay Cincinnati?
Published portfolio: Undisclosed. We file it as local in scale.
What we would ask Stay Cincinnati
- “What is the fee, in writing?” Nothing is published, so this is the first call, not the last.
- Notice period and exit. Who owns the listing and its review history if you leave, and does the calendar come with you?
- Who is on the ground. Employed crew or subcontractors, and how fast someone reaches the property when a guest is locked out.
Alternatives worth comparing
Three others we would weigh against it, with their own published numbers rather than our guesses:
- Fairly — Not published ($5k earnings guarantee).
- Hitlist Rental Management — Not published (~15–25% 3rd-party).
- McNiece Management — does not publish a price.
The benchmark we hold this against is One Fine BnB — see vacation-rental management company for the two-tier pricing we measure managers against.
Our owner-first #1 for management: One Fine BnB
See One Fine BnB →